Chapter 4. Materials and methods

Table of Contents
4.1. Study population
4.2. Methods
4.3. Statistical analysis

4.1. Study population

The study included 160 patients investigated because of suspected interstitial lung disease or asbestos exposure. Altogether 137 consecutive patients were admitted to the pulmonary departments of Päivärinne Hospital (Muhos, Finland) between February 1990 and August 1992 (I-III). The patients came from the province of Oulu in Northern Finland and had been referred to investigations mostly by general practitioners. These 137 patients underwent bronchofiberoscopy and bronchoalveolar lavage due to their symptoms and findings. The study was performed as part of the normal diagnostic procedures and the serum and BALF samples were split off from routine specimens. The clinical data, including the laboratory results and pulmonary function tests, were obtained from the case histories. The remaining 23 patients had undergone open lung biopsies between 1981 and 1998 (IV). Pulmonary specialists from the pulmonary clinics of Northern Finland had referred these patients to open lung biopsies. Their paraffin blocks of biopsy specimens were obtained from the pathology files at the Department of Pathology, University of Oulu, Finland, and the clinical data were obtained from the case histories.

Sixty patients out of the 137 were diagnosed as having sarcoidosis (I). Forty of them had non-parenchymal sarcoidosis (Stage 0-I in chest radiography), and 20 were con­sidered to have parenchymal involvement (Stage II-III in chest radiography). No visible changes in radiography were considered stage 0. Nodular hilar enlargement was the criterion for hilar adenopathy (Stage I). Reticular, nodular and/or linear patterns were criteria for parenchymal involvement (Fraser et al. 1994). All the patients in the former group were newly diagnosed, whereas five patients in the latter group had been formerly diagnosed as having sarcoidosis and two of them were on oral corticosteroid medication at the time of diagnosis. Histological confirmation of diagnosis was available for 35 patients with biopsies taken either transbronchially, via mediastinoscopy, from superficial lymph nodes or from the skin. Typical sarcoidosis changes were seen in 16 of the parenchymal and 19 of the non-parenchymal patients. In the remaining 25 cases the diagnosis was based on a typical clinical picture, marked lymphocytosis in BALF and typical findings in chest radiography as well as exclusion of other diseases. The clinical characteristics of the sarcoidosis patients are presented in table 2.

Fibrosing alveolitis was diagnosed in 18 of the 137 patients (II). Biopsies in 9 patients and autopsy in one patient confirmed the diagnosis. The diagnosis of the remaining 8 patients based on typical findings in chest radiography, BALF, spirometry and diffusion capacity, and the exclusion of other pulmonary diseases. Sixteen of these 18 patients were considered to have idiopathic fibrosing alveolitis, one patient had rheumatoid arthritis and one had scleroderma with pulmonary involvement. The mean follow-up time of these patients was 6 years and 2 months (range between 5 and 7 years). The clinical charac­teristics of the fibrosis patients are shown in table 2.

Table 2. Clinical characteristics of the patients with sarcoidosis and fibrosing alveolitis and the controls (I-II).

  SarcoidosisFibrosingalveolitisControls
Subjectsn601817
Ageyrs39 ± 9.561 ±7.747 ±9.1
SexM / F39 /295/139/8
Heightcm172±7.8159 ±7.0165 ±7.9
Weightkg77.3 ±13.772 ±15.973 ±15.3
FEV113.8 ±1.02.21 ±0.53.17 ±0.43
%pred95 ±16.283 ±9.493 ±11
FVC14.7 ±1.22.68 ±0.74.02 ±0.66
%pred94 ±14.481 ±10.497 ±10.1
DLCOmmol/min/kPa9.9 ±2.3, n=574.89 ±1.79.04 ±2.0 (n=16)
%pred102 ±16.671 ±21.8106 ±19.6
DLCO/VAmmol/min/kPa/11.67 ±0.3, n=571.30 ±0.331.68 ±0.3 (n=16)
%pred106 ±12.488 ±20.7108 ±17.8
Recovery of BALF ml136 ±12.0131 ±11.3128 ±14
BALF-albumin mg/ml113 ±11163.9 ±31.342.2 ±17.4
BALF-neutrophils%2.3 ±3.310.5 ±8.83.2 ±6.0
BALF--lymphocytes%37.9 ±18.016.6 ±14.118.1 ±13.1
BALF--eosinophils%1.4 ±1.51.1 ±2.40.1 ±0.5
Smokersn%14 (23)7 (39)5 (29)
Ex-smokersn%18 (30)3 (17)4 (24)
Nonsmokersn%28 (47)8 (44)8 (47)

Forty-two patients were referred to investigations due to a history of occupational asbestos exposure and changes in chest radiography (III). The radiological changes included either pleural plaques or an interstitial basal reticular-linear pattern suggestive of fibrosis and asbestosis. Five patients were diagnosed as having asbestosis, 25 had pleural plaques, and the chest radiographs of 12 patients were considered normal. In one patient the asbestosis diagnosis was based on an open lung biopsy. The remaining 4 patients with asbestosis had typical findings in chest radiography, spirometry and diffusion capacity and a significant but variable amount of asbestos bodies in BALF. Other pulmonary diseases were excluded. The mean follow-up time was 7 years (from 5 years 7 months to 7 years 10 months). The characteristics of the asbestos-exposed individuals are presented in table 3.

Table 3. Clinical characteristics of the patients exposed to asbestos fibres (III).

  AsbestosisNo parenchymal involvement
Subjectsn537
Ageyrs55 ± 9.654 ± 8.0
SexM / F5/037/0
Heightcm171 ±8.0171 ± 7.3
Weightkg76 ±7.478 ± 13.2
FEV112.76 ± 0.73.52 ± 0.7
%pred74 ± 2395 ± 22
FVC13.59 ± 0.94.44 ± 0.75
%pred78 ± 23951 ± 10
DLCOmmol/min/kPa5.48 ± 1.29.53 ± 1.61 (n=33)
%pred60 ± 10104 ± 15
DLCO/VAmmol/min/kPa/11.26 ± 0.51.59 ± 0.27 (n=31)
%pred84 ± 28107 ± 17
Recovery of BALF ml119 ± 8.9125 ± 17.9
BA mg/mlmg/ml39.2 ± 28.754.9 ± 21.5
BALF-neutrophils%2.0 ± 2.23.2 ± 4.0
BALF--lymphocytes%15.0 ± 14.615.0 ± 12.3
BALF--eosinophils%2.2 ± 2.71.5 ± 1.7
Smokersn%4 (75)9 (24)
Ex-smokersn%013 (35)
Nonsmokersn%1 (25)15 (41)

The control group (I-II) consisted of 17 subjects who underwent fiberoptic broncho­scopy because of prolonged cough, haemoptysis or other minor respiratory symptoms. Four of the patients were later considered asthmatic. There were no changes in the chest radiographs of this group. The characteristics of the control group are shown in table 2.

The Ethics Committee of Päivärinne Hospital approved the research protocol. Informed consent was obtained from each subject beforehand.

Twenty-three patients who had undergone open or thoracoscopic lung biopsy (IV) were drawn from the files of the Department of Pathology, University of Oulu. Histopathologically typical 10 cases with fibrosing alveolitis and 13 cases with sarcoidosis were re-evaluated. The diagnoses of the patients were based on light-microscopic evaluations using the previously described histological criteria (Dail & Hammer 1994, Thurlbeck & Churg 1995, Katzenstein 1997). The patients’ histological biopsies were investigated immunohistochemically. The clinical characteristics of the sarcoidosis patients are presented in table 4 and those of the fibrosing alveolitis patients in table 5.

Table 4. Characteristics of the patients with sarcoidosis in the immunohistochemical study (IV).

N:oAgeSexWeight kgHeight cmSmokingPost biobpsy treatmentACE U/1FEVFVCDLCODLCO/VA %pred
126F40144NonNone29*73817491
234M70183ExCortisone1209991100120
337M70179NonNone1829496112120
427M57180CurrentCortisone112981047177
555F65162NonCortisone9577787098
644F62167NonCortisone1929510398100
769F61153NonCortisone118951057674
855F73166NonCortisone1131181249787
957F67160NonNone63848096117
1035F59162NonCortisone12264786491
1158M69171NonNone95415387113
1252F57162NonCortisone**7784NANA
1345M77185CurrentNone197991037072
ACE: Angiotensin-converting enzyme, reference level 34-160 U/l ; NA: data not available; Non: Nonsmoker; Ex: Ex-smoker; Current: Current smoker. *: Reference level 14-46 U/l; **: ACE-inhibiting medication.

Table 5. Characteristics of the patients with fibrosing alveolitis in the immunohistochemical study (IV).

N:oAgeSexWeight kgHeight cmSmokingFollow-up monthsPost-biobpsy treatmentStatus at the end of follow-upFEV1 %predFVC %predDLCO %predDLCO/VA %pred
  159M84167Current36NoneNA921003642
  257F82165Non115CortFA85766479
  366F90164Non16Cort, AzaFA44433870
  443F77165Non176Cort, CycloAlive83853650
  558F74166Non45CortAlive656683102
  648F74164Non26Cort, CycloFA595287135
  744M89185Current7CortFA80715773
  866F85163Non40NoneAlive88857780
  963F69157Ex43NoneAlive81816775
1073M90172Non35CortAlive6360NANA
NA: data not available; FA: died of fibrosing alveolotis; Non: Nonsmoker; Ex: Ex-smoker; Current: Current smoker; Cort: Cortisone; Aza: Azathioprine; Cyclo: Cyclophosphamide.